15.1Selection of Alternatives — Para 234
In simple wordsIf there are two alternatives for the same work, choose the cheapest in the long run — comparison by Equivalent Annual Cost.
- When two or more alternatives provide the same service, selection is based on long-term minimum cost.
- Convert expenditures occurring at different times into Equivalent Annual Cost (EAC) — including interest.
- Project B may be better even with a higher total outlay if its major expenditure occurs later — because the Present Value of later expenditure is lower.
- Note — Interest is included in the comparison of alternatives (Para 204 Note), whereas it is not included in the DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) of a new project.
Equivalent Annual Cost (EAC)
- Capital Recovery Factor (CRF) = r ÷ [1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ] = 1 ÷ Annuity Factor
- EAC = Initial Cost × CRF + Annual Operating/Maintenance Cost (Subtract the effect of residual value, if any)
Example — At 10%, the 10-year annuity factor is 6.1446 → CRF = 0.1627. Comparison of two alternatives —
| Alternative | Initial Cost | Annual Maintenance | EAC |
|---|---|---|---|
| X | ₹10 lakh | ₹2.0 lakh | 10 × 0.1627 + 2.0 = ₹3.627 lakh |
| Y | ₹14 lakh | ₹1.2 lakh | 14 × 0.1627 + 1.2 = ₹3.478 lakh |
In detail
When two alternatives perform the same task but their initial cost and maintenance cost are different, they are compared using Equivalent Annual Cost (EAC) — i.e., converting the capital cost also into a "per year" cost and adding it to maintenance.
- Formula — EAC = Initial Cost × Capital Recovery Factor + Annual Maintenance. Here the factor is 0.1627 (based on 10% interest and 10-year life).
- Alternative X — Cheaper (₹10 lakh) but maintenance is expensive (₹2 lakh) → EAC = 1.627 + 2.0 = ₹3.627 lakh.
- Alternative Y — Expensive (₹14 lakh) but maintenance is cheaper (₹1.2 lakh) → EAC = 2.278 + 1.2 = ₹3.478 lakh.
- Decision — Y is cheaper, even though its initial cost is ₹4 lakh more — because the annual saving of ₹80,000 in maintenance is more than the cost of that extra capital. This is the lesson: Decisions should not be taken merely by looking at the initial cost.
→ Even with a higher initial cost, Y is cheaper (lower EAC).