14.1What is Included and What is Not in Cash Flow (Para 228 and General Principles)
In simple wordsIn DCF (Discounted Cash Flow), only real cash transactions are included — not non-cash items like Depreciation.
Summary Table
| Included (✔) | Not Included (✘) |
|---|---|
| Capital Cost — Year-wise (in the year it is spent) | Depreciation (not a cash flow) |
| Cost of Rolling Stock (Para 208) | Sunk Cost (previously completed surveys, etc.) |
| Additional Working Capital (stores stock, etc.) — return at the end | Provisions and other accounting adjustments |
| Operating & Maintenance Expenses | Interest on new projects (already included in the discount rate) |
| Additional (Incremental) Net Earnings — only realizable revenue | Savings that would have occurred even without the project |
| Savings in expenditure | "Savings" resulting from a loss to another Railway/unit |
| Residual / Salvage Value — in the year it is expected (Para 233) | Traffic possible with existing capacity |
| Expenditure on major renewals/overhauls in between |
In detail
The correct calculation of DCF depends on what to add and what not to add to the cash flow. The basic question for every item is the same: "Will this amount actually come in or go out as cash in the future because of this project?"
- Included — Capital cost (in the year spent); cost of rolling stock; additional working capital (including return at the end); operating and maintenance expenses; incremental net earnings (only realizable); savings in expenditure; major intermediate renewals; and residual value at the end.
- Not Included — Because they are not cash — Depreciation, provisions, and accounting adjustments; and interest (already present in the discount rate).
- Not Included — Because they are not due to the project — Sunk cost (previously completed survey — that has been spent whether the project happens or not); savings that would have occurred even without the project; "savings" resulting from a loss to another unit; and traffic possible with existing capacity.
- Example — A new line will bring ₹50 crore traffic, but out of that, ₹20 crore traffic is merely shifting from an existing line; therefore, only the incremental earning of ₹30 crore will be taken in DCF.
- Para 228 — Only realizable revenue and cash expenditure in cash flow; no depreciation and provisions.
- Reason — It is inherent in DCF arithmetic that as long as the PV (Present Value — at the prescribed rate) of cash flows equals the investment, the invested capital remains intact; subtracting depreciation would lead to double counting.