19.1Three-tier System (GCC 2022)
In simple wordsThree levels of dispute resolution — Conciliation → DAB (Dispute Adjudication Board) → Arbitration.
Summary Table
| Level | When | Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Conciliation — Para 63 | Advertised value of tender up to (including) ₹50 crore | Sole Conciliator; settlement by mutual consent |
| Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) — Para 63.2 | Advertised value more than ₹50 crore | Members — Retired senior officers etc.; Decision |
| Arbitration — Para 64 | If not resolved by Conciliation/DAB | Under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 |
In detail
Dispute resolution in GCC 2022 is a ladder — first an attempt at consensual solution, and only if it fails, then Arbitration.
- First Level — According to contract size — Conciliation (Para 63): In contracts with advertised value up to ₹50 crore — a conciliator attempts to bring both parties to a consensual agreement. Dispute Adjudication Board — DAB (Para 63.2): In contracts above ₹50 crore — a board consisting of members like retired senior officers, which gives a decision. DAB is used in large contracts because disputes there are complex and require immediate decisions.
- Second Level — Arbitration (Para 64) — If not resolved by Conciliation or DAB — under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
The objective of this sequence is that most disputes get resolved in a cheap and fast manner at the first stage itself.
- Similar framework in EPC (Engineering, Procurement and Construction) contracts — Clause 24.1 (Conciliation), 24.2 (DAB), 24.3 (Statutory Arbitration Tribunal – SAT); In EPC, DAB must be constituted within 90 days of the agreement.