रेल डिपार्टमेंटल तैयारीRail Departmental Taiyari — रेलवे विभागीय परीक्षाओं की तैयारीLogin / Open app

Action on the Inquiry Report (Rule 10), UPSC/CVC Consultation and Communication of Orders (Rule 12)

D&A Rules, Conduct, PNM/JCM • Part 9 / 27 • Appendix-III A IREM Examination

हिंदी में पढ़ें

In this part

  1. Rule 10 — Action of the DA on the Inquiry Report
  2. The DA's Order — a "Speaking Order"
  3. Consultation with the UPSC (Commission)
  4. CVC — First and Second Stage Advice (Two-stage advice)
  5. Rule 12 — Communication of Orders
  6. When an Order Takes Effect — Practical Points
  7. Examples

First sub-topic (sample)

1Rule 10 — Action of the DA on the Inquiry Report

In simple words

On receiving the IO's report, the DA sends it to the employee, looks at his representation, and then decides — recording reasons if he disagrees.

Summary table

Stage Provision
10(1)(a) — Copy of the report The DA (when not itself the IO) sends a copy of the inquiry report to the employee; if the DA disagrees with any finding of the IO (Inquiry Officer), it also sends its tentative reasons for disagreement (disagreement note)
Representation The employee gives a written representation within 15 days — whether the report is in his favour or against him
10(1)(b) — Further inquiry The DA may, for reasons in writing, remit the case to the same or a new IO for further inquiry/additional evidence — the IO then inquires further as per Rule 9
10(2) — Disagreement If the DA disagrees with the IO's finding, it may record its own reasons and give its own finding — if the evidence is sufficient
Beyond its competence If in the DA's opinion a penalty is warranted that it cannot impose itself, it sends the entire record to the competent DA — the competent DA acts on the evidence (and may get a further inquiry held if it wishes)
10(3) — Minor penalty DA's opinion that a minor penalty is warranted → may impose the minor penalty notwithstanding Rule 11, without giving any further opportunity (with consultation with the Commission where necessary)
10(4) — Major penalty DA's opinion that a major penalty is warranted → imposes the major penalty; a separate "show cause" opportunity on the proposed penalty is not necessary (42nd Amendment)
Exoneration If none of the charges is proved → order of exoneration, communicated to the employee
In detail

Rule 10 governs what the disciplinary authority does after the inquiry. It sends a copy of the inquiry report to the employee, together with its own tentative reasons if it disagrees with any finding, and the employee may make a written representation within 15 days, whether the report is for or against him. The DA may remit the case for further inquiry, recording reasons.

If it disagrees with the inquiry officer, it records its own findings where the evidence is sufficient. If it considers a penalty beyond its powers is warranted, it sends the record to the competent authority. If a minor penalty is warranted, it may impose one without further opportunity; if a major penalty, it imposes it without a separate show-cause notice on the penalty (after the 42nd Amendment). If no charge is proved, it passes an order of exoneration.

  • Mohd. Ramzan Khan (1991) and ECIL vs Karunakar (1993) — supplying a copy of the report is compulsory; non-supply vitiates the order only if there is actual prejudice.
  • The disagreement note must contain the DA's "tentative" reasons, not a final decision — so that the employee gets a real opportunity to respond to them (principle of Punjab National Bank vs Kunj Behari Misra, 1998).
Full preparation in the app

All parts in Hindi + English, subject-wise MCQs and mock tests — create a free account.

Start free
‹ Previous: Procedure for Major Penalties (Rule 9) — Part 2: Regular Hearing, Evidence, Ex-parte Inquiry and the Inquiry ReportAll parts — D&A Rules, Conduct, PNM/JCMNext: Procedure for Minor Penalties — Rule 11 (SF-11) ›
All exams & subjects (Hindi) • Login • शिक्षक भर्ती (RPSC / REET) नोट्स • Telegram channel • गोपनीयता नीति • नियम व शर्तें • संपर्क