1Rule 11(1) — General Procedure
In simple wordsA hearing even before a minor punishment — telling the employee of the proposal through SF-11 and giving him a chance to make a representation.
Except under Rule 10(3) and Rule 14, no Minor Penalty may be imposed unless —
| Clause | Provision |
|---|---|
| (a) | The employee is informed in writing of the proposal to take action against him, along with a statement of the imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour — and given an opportunity to make a representation against the proposal (form SF-11) |
| (b) | An inquiry is held as per sub-rules (6) to (25) of Rule 9 if in the DA's opinion it is necessary |
| (c) | The employee's representation and the record of the inquiry under (b) are considered |
| (d) | Findings on each imputation are recorded |
| (e) | The Commission (UPSC — Union Public Service Commission) is consulted where necessary |
Rule 11(1) lays down the procedure for imposing a minor penalty, which is simpler than a full inquiry. The employee is informed in writing of the proposal and given a statement of the imputations, with an opportunity to make a representation. An inquiry under Rule 9 is held only if the disciplinary authority considers it necessary.
The authority then considers the representation and any inquiry record, records findings on each imputation, and consults the UPSC where necessary. For example, a clerk charged with delay in disposing of files is given a memorandum (SF-11), replies, and if the DA is not satisfied, a censure may be imposed without a full inquiry.
- Time limit for the representation: within 10 days of receiving SF-11 (the DA may extend it).
- The employee may ask for inspection of documents — the DA should normally allow it.
- If the employee asks for an inquiry → the DA decides on it with due consideration; if it refuses, reasons are recorded (mechanical refusals have been set aside by the courts).
- SF-11(b) — for the decision/intimation to hold a detailed inquiry in a minor penalty case.