9.1Para 204 — Fundamental Rule
In simple wordsA net financial gain is required from the investment — either through savings in expenditure or an increase in earnings.
- Expected net financial gain from the project — (a) Savings in expenditure, or (b) Increase in net earnings (Gross Earnings − Working Expenses), or (c) both.
- Residential buildings, assisted sidings and rolling stock — special rules apply to these; in addition to these —
- No new investment proposal will be considered financially justified unless it is shown that after meeting working expenses (or average annual service cost), the net profit will yield a return of at least 10% on the initial Estimated Cost using the DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) method.
- Basis — Railway Board letter F(X)-II/2011/ROR/1 dated 05.10.2017.
History of Minimum Return (For Examination)
| Period | Minimum DCF Return |
|---|---|
| Original Code Provision | 10% |
| Subsequently through Board instructions (until before 2017) | 14% — Ministry's replies in Parliament (2006, 2011, 2013, 2014): "Projects with more than 14% return are financially remunerative"; CAG (Comptroller and Auditor General) reports also used the 14% benchmark |
| From 05.10.2017 (Present) | 10% — Finance Code (2022 Edition) Para 204 |
| May 2026 (News) — New Board guidelines | To maintain FIRR (Financial Internal Rate of Return) of at least 10% |
In detail
To consider a project "remunerative," its DCF return must be above a minimum threshold. This threshold has changed over time — and it is a favorite question for exams.
- Original Code — 10%.
- Later, until before 2017 — 14% through Board instructions — the Ministry also stated in Parliament that projects with a return higher than 14% are remunerative.
- From 05.10.2017 (Present) — 10% again — and this is in the 2022 Finance Code edition (Para 204). The reason for lowering the limit was that 14% was very high and many essential capacity-augmentation projects did not meet that criteria.
- May 2026 — New Board guidelines — FIRR (Financial Internal Rate of Return) of at least 10%.
Remember: 10% → 14% → 10% (Since 2017).
Note14% is found in old question papers/books; the current rule is 10%. If the question contains "Current"/"2022 Edition"/"Para 204," then 10%.
Notes on Para 204 (Summary)
- If construction lasts for more than one year, the interest during construction should be added to the project cost (excluding the revenue-chargeable portion).
- Calculation of Depreciation is on the Total Cost (in the average annual cost method).
- Maintenance of bridges — relevant charges in addition to the bridge itself.
- Interest is not included in the working expenses of new projects; but interest is included in the comparison of alternatives.
- In DCF, depreciation is ignored as an element of working expenses (Para 228).