रेल डिपार्टमेंटल तैयारीRail Departmental Taiyari — रेलवे विभागीय परीक्षाओं की तैयारीLogin / Open app

Test of Remunerativeness — Para 204–205

Associated Finance & Appraisal • Part 9 / 21 • Appendix-III A IREM Examination

हिंदी में पढ़ें

In this part

  1. Para 204 — Fundamental Rule
  2. Para 205 — For which investments the test is mandatory (Illustrative list)
  3. Types of Gain — What should be counted
  4. What should not be counted

First sub-topic (sample)

9.1Para 204 — Fundamental Rule

In simple words

A net financial gain is required from the investment — either through savings in expenditure or an increase in earnings.

History of Minimum Return (For Examination)

Period Minimum DCF Return
Original Code Provision 10%
Subsequently through Board instructions (until before 2017) 14% — Ministry's replies in Parliament (2006, 2011, 2013, 2014): "Projects with more than 14% return are financially remunerative"; CAG (Comptroller and Auditor General) reports also used the 14% benchmark
From 05.10.2017 (Present) 10% — Finance Code (2022 Edition) Para 204
May 2026 (News) — New Board guidelines To maintain FIRR (Financial Internal Rate of Return) of at least 10%
In detail

To consider a project "remunerative," its DCF return must be above a minimum threshold. This threshold has changed over time — and it is a favorite question for exams.

  • Original Code — 10%.
  • Later, until before 2017 — 14% through Board instructions — the Ministry also stated in Parliament that projects with a return higher than 14% are remunerative.
  • From 05.10.2017 (Present) — 10% again — and this is in the 2022 Finance Code edition (Para 204). The reason for lowering the limit was that 14% was very high and many essential capacity-augmentation projects did not meet that criteria.
  • May 2026 — New Board guidelines — FIRR (Financial Internal Rate of Return) of at least 10%.

Remember: 10% → 14% → 10% (Since 2017).

Note

14% is found in old question papers/books; the current rule is 10%. If the question contains "Current"/"2022 Edition"/"Para 204," then 10%.

Notes on Para 204 (Summary)

  1. If construction lasts for more than one year, the interest during construction should be added to the project cost (excluding the revenue-chargeable portion).
  2. Calculation of Depreciation is on the Total Cost (in the average annual cost method).
  3. Maintenance of bridges — relevant charges in addition to the bridge itself.
  4. Interest is not included in the working expenses of new projects; but interest is included in the comparison of alternatives.
  5. In DCF, depreciation is ignored as an element of working expenses (Para 228).
Full preparation in the app

All parts in Hindi + English, subject-wise MCQs and mock tests — create a free account.

Start free
‹ Previous: Financial Appraisal of Projects — General Principles (Finance Code Vol. I, Chapter II)All parts — Associated Finance & AppraisalNext: Rolling Stock, Traction, Earnings Estimates and Cost Concepts (Para 208–217) ›
All exams & subjects (Hindi) • Login • शिक्षक भर्ती (RPSC / REET) नोट्स • Telegram channel • गोपनीयता नीति • नियम व शर्तें • संपर्क