2.1Based on Pricing
In simple wordsBased on how payment is made — Item Rate (item-wise rate), Lump Sum, or Cost + Profit, etc.
Summary Table
| Type | How it works | Use / Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Item Rate Contract | Contractor quotes a separate rate for every item; payment = actual quantity × item rate | Most common in Railways; works involving Non-Schedule (NS) items |
| Percentage Rate Contract | At rates of Indian Railway Schedule of Rates (SOR) — e.g., USSOR (Unified Standard Schedule of Rates) — x% above/below/at par | Works with standard items; same percentage applicable to all SOR items |
| Lump Sum Contract | A fixed amount for the entire specified work | Scope of work is fully defined (e.g., standard building); quantity-risk rests with the contractor |
| EPC (Engineering, Procurement & Construction) | Design, material procurement, and construction by a single contractor; generally fixed price (lump sum) | Large projects — new line, doubling, electrification; Railway's standard EPC document |
| Turnkey | Handing over the work in a commissioned/operational state ("Turn the key and operate") | Plants / systems |
| Cost Plus | Actual cost + fixed percentage/fee | Extraordinary works with uncertain scope; difficult to control — discouraged |
Item Rate vs. Percentage Rate — Difference
| Point | Item Rate | Percentage Rate |
|---|---|---|
| What the contractor quotes | Rate for each item | A single percentage on SOR |
| Comparison | L1 decided by item-wise grand total | L1 decided by the percentage |
| Variation | Item-wise limits | Separate limit for variation in SOR items |
| Risk | Unbalanced rates (front loading) possible in individual items | Lesser imbalance |
In a tender, a contractor can quote rates in two ways, and both have their own benefits and risks.
- Item Rate — The contractor quotes a separate rate for every item; L1 (lowest) is decided by the grand total of all items. Risk — The contractor can quote a higher rate for certain items (which are to be executed early or whose quantities are likely to increase) and a lower rate for others to show a lower grand total — this is called unbalanced rates or front loading. Example — Higher rate in earthwork (which is done first) and very low in finishing — the contractor gets money early, and the risk of abandoning the work later increases.
- Percentage Rate — The contractor quotes a single percentage on the Schedule of Rates (SOR) (e.g., 5% below or above SOR); L1 is decided on that same percentage. Since the same percentage applies to all items, imbalance is less.
- Variation — Item-wise limits in Item Rate; separate limits for variation of SOR items in Percentage Rate.
Unbalanced rates — The contractor quotes very high rates for some items and very low for others to gain from items whose quantities are likely to increase. The Tender Committee and Member (Finance) should also examine the reasonableness of item-wise rates.
Example — How unbalanced rates cause loss: Two items in a tender — earthwork (estimated 1,000 cubic meters) and rock cutting (estimated 100 cubic meters).
| Bidder | Earthwork Rate | Rock Cutting Rate | Tender Value | Actual payment when 300 cubic meters of rock turns up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| X | ₹300 | ₹1,500 | ₹4,50,000 | ₹3,00,000 + ₹4,50,000 = ₹7,50,000 |
| Y | ₹240 | ₹2,000 | ₹4,40,000 (L1) | ₹2,40,000 + ₹6,00,000 = ₹8,40,000 |
Y quoted a higher rate on the item whose quantity was likely to increase — despite being L1 in the tender, it ended up being ₹90,000 costlier. Therefore, the Tender Committee checks the reasonableness of item-wise rates and the realism of quantities.
Example — Percentage Rate: SOR value of work is ₹2.00 crore. If the contractor quotes "4.5% above" → Contract Value is ₹2.09 crore; if they quote "3% below" → ₹1.94 crore. Payment for every SOR item is made by applying this percentage to its SOR rate.