1Permanent Negotiating Machinery (PNM)
In simple wordsPNM = Regular consultation between recognized federations and administration at three levels.
Why was PNM formed? Railways are a public utility service — a strike can paralyze transport across the entire country. Therefore, in 1951 it was decided that collective demands and grievances of employees should be resolved within a permanent, regular framework of consultation so that the situation does not lead to confrontation. It includes only recognized unions/federations, ensuring clear representation in negotiations.
Example — How an issue moves forward in PNM: Trackmaintainers in a division are not receiving adequate safety equipment (torch, jacket) for night patrolling.
- The recognized union raises this in the divisional level PNM meeting → If a procurement decision is made at the DRM (Divisional Railway Manager) level, the matter ends there.
- If the matter involves policy or funds beyond the powers of the division → PNM meeting with headquarters/GM.
- If the matter relates to all-India railway policy (such as a new allowance or change in rules), the federation (AIRF/NFIR) raises it in the Railway Board level PNM.
- If agreement is not reached between the Board and the federation on a matter of sufficient importance → Ad hoc Railway Tribunal (rare).
Summary Table
| Point | Description |
|---|---|
| Establishment | Developed in December 1951 through talks between the Railway Board and organized labor; effective from 1.1.1952 |
| Objective | To maintain contact with organized labor and settle differences/disputes between railway administration and workers |
| Basis | IREM (Indian Railway Establishment Manual) Volume-II, Chapter 26 |
| Who can participate | Only recognized unions/federations |
Three Levels of PNM
| Level | Arrangement |
|---|---|
| 1. Railway Level | Recognized unions — first with divisional officers, then with headquarters officers, including the General Manager |
| 2. Railway Board Level | Matters not resolved at the railway level or matters within the powers of the Board — Federations (AIRF, NFIR) with the Railway Board; meetings generally every quarter, separately with both federations |
| 3. Ad hoc Railway Tribunal | When consensus is not reached between the federation and the Railway Board on a matter of sufficient importance — Tribunal with equal representatives of rail labor and rail administration and a neutral Chairman |
The three levels of PNM are a ladder — every issue is first raised at the lowest level, and only moves up if not resolved there.
- 1. Railway Level — Recognized unions first talk to divisional officers, then to headquarters officers (including the General Manager). Most local issues (running rooms, quarters, rosters) are resolved here.
- 2. Railway Board Level — Matters that are not resolved at the railway level, or are within the power of the Board (policy), are discussed by the federations (AIRF, NFIR) with the Railway Board — generally every quarter, separately with both federations.
- 3. Ad hoc Railway Tribunal — When the federation and the Board do not agree on a matter of sufficient importance — equal representatives of rail labor and administration and a neutral Chairman. Its decisions are not binding on the government — the government may accept, reject, or modify them.
- Use of ad hoc tribunals — 1953, 1969 (Railway Labour Tribunal — Justice N.M. Miabhoy, single-member; report August 1972, all recommendations accepted) and 1973 (five issues between AIRF and Board).
- Restructuring after SBE-2024 — Restructuring of Board-level PNM and DC/JCM scheme — Board letter dated 27.01.2025.