1Rule 25(1) — Who May Revise
In simple wordsEven after an appeal — higher officers can reduce, enhance or set aside a punishment through Revision.
Notwithstanding anything in the rules, the following authorities may, on their own motion (suo motu) or on an application, call for the record of any inquiry and revise any order made under these rules (or the old rules repealed by Rule 29):
| No. | Revising Authority | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| (i) | President | — |
| (ii) | Railway Board | — |
| (iii) | General Manager (GM) or an authority of that level | Over an employee under his control |
| (iv) | Appellate Authority — not below the level of DRM (Divisional Railway Manager) | Only when no appeal has been preferred |
| (v) | Any other authority — not below the level of Deputy Head of Department (Deputy HOD) | Over an employee under its control |
Rule 25(1) lists who may revise an order. The President and the Railway Board may revise any order. The General Manager or an authority of that level may revise orders concerning employees under his control.
The appellate authority, if not below the level of DRM, may revise only when no appeal has been preferred. Any other authority not below Deputy Head of Department may revise orders concerning employees under its control. Revision lets a higher authority correct an order on its own motion, even when the employee has not appealed.
- Consultation with the Commission (UPSC — Union Public Service Commission), where necessary.
What the Revising Authority may do:
- (a) confirm, modify or set aside the order;
- (b) confirm, reduce, enhance or set aside the penalty — or impose a penalty where none was imposed;
- (c) remit the case to the original or any other authority with directions for further inquiry;
- (d) pass any other appropriate order.
Provisos (safeguards):
- (a) before imposing or enhancing a penalty, a reasonable opportunity of making a representation against the proposed penalty;
- (b) if a major penalty (v)–(ix) or withholding of increments under 11(2) is proposed/to be enhanced to that level and no inquiry was held earlier → an inquiry under Rule 9 (except cases under Rule 14); consultation with the Commission where necessary.