1Levels of Financial Control
In simple wordsPublic money has several guards — Parliament (gives permission), the Board down to branch officers (spend through distributed powers), Ministry of Finance (holds back or releases cash), budgetary control (the limit of the grant), Accounts Department (checks bills and advises beforehand) and the C&AG (independent examination afterwards).
Remember two words: ex-ante = before the decision (advice of Associated Finance), ex-post = after the expenditure (audit by the C&AG).
Process of budgetary control (sequence)
- Distribution (allotment) of the sanctioned grant among units/officers.
- Record of expenditure and liabilities by every spending officer — a liability also burdens the budget of the same year.
- Monthly expenditure statement from the Accounts Department — comparison with the budget.
- Likely excess → proposal for re-appropriation (पुनर्विनियोग) / Supplementary Grant; likely savings → timely surrender.
- Reassessment at the time of the Revised Estimates (RE); at year-end the Final Modification (final redistribution within the grant).
- Later, the Appropriation Accounts (विनियोग लेखे) — with reasons for variations.
ExampleA division has an allotment of ₹5 crore for repairs. By October ₹3 crore has been spent and bills of ₹1.5 crore are payable (liability) — so ₹4.5 crore is actually committed. If ₹1 crore more of work is due by December, the shortfall is obvious → a proposal for re-appropriation in good time. Conversely, if savings are visible, surrender them in time instead of waiting till March.
Summary table
| Level | Who | How |
|---|---|---|
| Parliamentary | Parliament | Voting on the budget, Appropriation Act, supplementary/Excess Grant, PAC (Public Accounts Committee), Estimates Committee, Standing Committee |
| Executive | Ministry/Board → GM (General Manager) → PHOD/DRM → branch officer | Delegation of Powers, sanctions, monitoring |
| Exchequer | Ministry of Finance | Control over Cash Flow — monthly/quarterly expenditure limits |
| Budgetary | Spending officers + Accounts | Keeping expenditure within the limit of the grant; re-appropriation/surrender |
| Internal Check | Accounts Department | Scrutiny of bills, inspections |
| Associated Finance | Accounts Department (financial adviser) | Before the decision — ex-ante |
| Audit | C&AG (Comptroller and Auditor General) | After the expenditure — ex-post |