1Financial procedure in Parliament — Articles 110 to 117
In simple wordsThe Government can spend even one rupee only when Parliament permits. The budget is laid (112), the Lok Sabha votes on the Demands for Grants (113), and then the Appropriation Bill (114) gives the legal permission to draw the money. If more money is needed during the year, there are supplementary/additional/excess grants (115), and to carry on until the budget is passed, a vote on account (116).
- Money Bill (110): A Bill relating to taxes, borrowing, money from the Consolidated/Contingency Fund, appropriation etc. is a Money Bill. Whether a Bill is a Money Bill — the Speaker of the Lok Sabha's decision is final. The Rajya Sabha can hold it only for 14 days and can only make recommendations.
- Budget (112): The President causes the Annual Financial Statement to be laid before Parliament every year. In it charged and other (voted) expenditure are shown separately, and expenditure on revenue account is shown separately from other expenditure. 112(3) gives the list of charged expenditure.
- Voting (113): There is no vote on charged expenditure, but it can be discussed. Other expenditure is placed before the Lok Sabha for vote in the form of Demands for Grants. The Lok Sabha can assent to, refuse or reduce a demand — it cannot increase it. No demand can be made except on the recommendation of the President.
- Appropriation Bill (114): The Bill for withdrawing money from the Consolidated Fund for the grants passed and the charged expenditure. No amendment varying the charged amounts can be moved to it. No money can be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund except under appropriation made by law.
Three kinds of later grants (115):
- Supplementary — the amount authorised for the year turns out to be insufficient;
- Additional — for a new service not contemplated in the budget;
- Excess — after the year is over, to regularise expenditure already incurred in excess of the grant (after the PAC's recommendation).
Three kinds of special grants (116):
- Vote on account — an advance for part of the year's expenditure until the budget is passed;
- Vote of credit — for an uncertain/extraordinary demand whose amount cannot be stated in advance;
- Exceptional grant — for a purpose that is not part of the current service of any financial year.
117: Special provisions on Financial Bills — the President's recommendation, introduced only in the Lok Sabha.
ExampleIn the railways' Demand for Grant, ₹1,00,000 crore was sanctioned for salaries. Due to a DA increase ₹3,000 crore more is needed → supplementary grant (115). Expenditure on an entirely new scheme → additional grant (115). After the year ended it was found that ₹50 crore more had been spent under a grant → excess grant (115) after the PAC's recommendation.
Charged expenditure — main items in 112(3)
- Emoluments of the President and the expenditure of his office.
- Salaries and allowances of the Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and the Speaker and Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha.
- Debt charges of the Government of India (interest, sinking funds etc.).
- Salaries, allowances and pensions of the judges of the Supreme Court; pensions of High Court judges.
- Salary, allowances and pension of the C&AG (Comptroller and Auditor General) (and the administrative expenses of his office — Article 148(6)).
- Sums required to satisfy any judgment/decree of a court/tribunal.
- Any other expenditure declared charged by Parliament by law.
Why charged: to protect the independence of these offices and obligations — if the salaries of the C&AG or the judges were decided by vote every year, they could be pressured.
Summary table
| Article | Subject | Main points |
|---|---|---|
| 110 | Money Bill | Speaker's decision final; Rajya Sabha 14 days, recommendations only |
| 112 | Annual Financial Statement | Charged and voted separate; revenue account separate; 112(3) charged list |
| 113 | Procedure on estimates | Charged — discussion, no vote; demands in the Lok Sabha; assent/refuse/reduce — cannot increase; President's recommendation |
| 114 | Appropriation Bill | No money from the Consolidated Fund without appropriation by law |
| 115 | Supplementary / additional / excess | Insufficient / new service / excess expenditure after the year (PAC) |
| 116 | Vote on account / vote of credit / exceptional grant | Advance / uncertain demand / outside the current service |
| 117 | Financial Bill | President's recommendation, only in the Lok Sabha |
Exam trapCharged expenditure can be discussed, not voted. Demands for Grants are voted only in the Lok Sabha. A demand cannot be increased. "Additional grant" = new service; "excess grant" = expenditure beyond the grant.