1Legal basis
In simple wordsEvery purchase order is a legal contract. So two laws stand behind it — the Indian Contract Act 1872 (when any contract is valid, what happens on breach) and the Sale of Goods Act 1930 (ownership and quality in the sale of goods).
Indian Contract Act 1872
| Provision | Gist |
|---|---|
| Elements of a valid contract | Offer + acceptance, consideration, competent parties, free consent, lawful object |
| Section 73 | Compensation for loss caused by breach of contract |
| Section 74 | A sum fixed in the contract in advance (LD — Liquidated Damages) — only up to reasonable compensation |
| Section 56 | Impossibility (frustration) — a contract that becomes impossible is void |
| Constitution Article 299 | Government contracts are made in the name of the President, by an authorised officer |
Supply contracts rest on general contract law. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a valid contract needs an offer and acceptance, consideration, competent parties, free consent and a lawful object. Section 73 allows compensation for loss caused by breach of contract.
Section 74 deals with a sum fixed in advance in the contract, such as liquidated damages, and allows recovery only up to reasonable compensation. Section 56 says that a contract which becomes impossible to perform is void (frustration). For government contracts, Article 299 of the Constitution requires them to be made in the name of the President and executed by an authorised officer; a contract not made in that form does not bind the Government.
Landmark contract-law cases (in short — the principle)
| Case | Principle |
|---|---|
| Hadley v Baxendale (1854) | Damages for breach only for losses arising naturally or within both parties' contemplation at the time of contract — not remote losses (basis of Indian s.73) |
| Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893) | An offer to the public at large (reward advertisement) is a valid offer; performing the condition is acceptance |
| Harvey v Facey (1893) | Quoting the lowest price is not an offer — only information / invitation to treat |
| Fisher v Bell (1961) | Display with a price tag = invitation to treat; the customer makes the offer |
| Hyde v Wrench (1840) | A counter-offer destroys the original offer |
| Balfour v Balfour (1919) | Domestic promises between spouses — no intention to create legal relations presumed |
| Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt (1913) | An act done without knowledge of the offer is not acceptance — no claim to the reward |
| Krell v Henry (1903) | If the very purpose of the contract fails, it is frustrated — Indian s.56 |
| Felthouse v Bindley (1862) | Silence is not acceptance; acceptance must be communicated |
Lesson for procurement: a tender/quotation = offer; the Railway's NIT = invitation to treat; deviations from the bid in the detailed agreement can amount to a counter-offer — so obtain the bidder's clear acceptance; fixing likely loss in advance as LD is better.
Sale of Goods Act 1930
- Transfer of property — as per the terms of the contract (often after inspection and delivery);
- Implied conditions — goods must correspond with the description (Section 15), be of merchantable quality and fit for purpose (Section 16), and correspond with the sample (Section 17);
- Rights of seller and buyer — rejection, compensation.
GST
- Taxes shown separately in the bid; HSN (Harmonised System of Nomenclature) code;
- Input tax credit and e-invoice;
- GST (Goods and Services Tax) TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) 2% (Stores Accounts, sub-topic 4).