Basic sourcesConstitution Articles 112–117, 148–151, 266–267; C&AG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act 1971; Indian Railways Finance Code Vol. I (para 116 — financial propriety); Indian Railways Accounts Code. This part is a summary for non-accounts officers — the detail is in Parts 1.1, 1.2, 1.5 and 1.6 of the AFA section.
1Parliamentary Financial Control — Articles of the Constitution
In simple wordsThe Government can neither levy a tax nor take money out of the Consolidated Fund without a law of Parliament.
The Government cannot levy any tax without a law of Parliament (Article 265) and cannot withdraw any money from the Consolidated Fund without Parliament's Appropriation Act (Article 114(3)). This is the basis of parliamentary financial control. The same applies to the Railways, because all the Railways' revenue goes into the Consolidated Fund of India and all their expenditure is met from it.
| Article | Subject | Point to remember |
|---|---|---|
| 112 | Annual Financial Statement (budget) | Charged and voted expenditure shown separately |
| 113 | Demands for grants | The Lok Sabha can assent to, refuse or reduce a demand, not increase it; no vote on charged expenditure, only discussion |
| 114 | Appropriation Act | Without it no money comes out of the Consolidated Fund |
| 115 | Supplementary, additional and excess grants | Excess grant — after the expenditure has been incurred, on the PAC's recommendation |
| 116 | Vote on account, vote of credit, exceptional grant | Vote on account — an advance grant for a few months until the budget is passed |
| 266 | Consolidated Fund and Public Account | The Public Account holds provident funds, deposits, reserve funds, etc.; no vote on withdrawals from it |
| 267 | Contingency Fund of India | Under the President; advances for unforeseen expenditure (₹30,000 crore), recouped later from Parliament |
| 148–151 | Comptroller and Auditor General of India (C&AG) | See section 4 below |
Cut motions
- Policy cut — demand reduced to ₹1; disagreement with the policy
- Economy cut — reduction by a specified amount
- Token cut — reduction by ₹100; on a particular grievance
Special to the Railways
- Railway budget merged with the general budget from 2017-18; budget on 1 February
- A single demand for grants for the Ministry of Railways
- Charged expenditure of the Railways — mainly payment of court decrees and arbitration awards
2Public Accountability — Who Answers to Whom
In simple wordsThe chain of accountability for money — Parliament → Ministry of Railways → GM/PHOD/DRM → officers below.
Chain: Parliament — makes the grant → Ministry of Railways (Board) — the controlling officer → GM, PHOD, DRM — control of sub-allotments of the grant → appropriation accounts + C&AG's report → Public Accounts Committee (PAC) — examination → Ministry — Action Taken Note (ATN).
- Controlling officer (GFR Rule 26) — ensures that expenditure from the grant is within the sanctioned limit, on the right purpose and according to the rules; savings surrendered in time.
- Appropriation accounts — the account of grant vs actual expenditure; reasons must be given for large variations.
- Parliamentary committees: Public Accounts Committee (PAC) — 22 members (15 Lok Sabha + 7 Rajya Sabha), term 1 year, Chairman from the opposition since 1967; Estimates Committee — 30 members, all from the Lok Sabha; Committee on Public Undertakings (COPU) — 22; Department-Related Standing Committees (DRSC, since 1993) — examine the demands for grants.
3Canons of Financial Propriety
In simple wordsFollowing the rules is not enough — the expenditure must also be proper; the same care as when spending one's own money.
Following the rules alone is not enough; expenditure must also be proper. The canons of Finance Code Vol. I para 116 (the same idea is in GFR 2017 Rule 21):
- Every officer should exercise the same vigilance in spending Government money as a person of ordinary prudence would over his own money; expenditure should not be prima facie more than the occasion demands.
- No authority should sanction expenditure that benefits itself, directly or indirectly.
- Government money should not be used for the benefit of a particular person or section, unless — (a) the amount is insignificant, or (b) the claim could be enforced in a court of law, or (c) the expenditure is in line with a recognised policy or custom.
- Allowances granted to meet a particular kind of expenditure should not, on the whole, become a source of profit to the recipient.
ExampleA DRM sanctions new furniture for his own bungalow although the old one is serviceable — a violation of canons 1 and 2 (more than needed, and his own benefit). A "goodwill" payment to a contractor outside the contract — a violation of canon 3, because the claim is neither enforceable in a court nor covered by a recognised policy.
Finance concurrence: where the Schedule of Powers (SOP) requires it, the concurrence of the Accounts Department is obtained on a proposal. Finance's opinion is advice; disagreement is recorded on the file. If there is disagreement with the PFA at GM level, the case has to be referred to the Railway Board.
4Organisation of the C&AG and the CGA
In simple wordsC&AG = the country's auditor (under the Constitution); CGA = the head of the Central Government's accounts — the two are separate.
Comptroller and Auditor General of India (C&AG)
- Article 148 — appointed by the President; term 6 years or up to the age of 65; removable only like a Supreme Court judge
- 149 — duties and powers (by law of Parliament — the DPC Act 1971)
- 150 — accounts of the Union and the States in the form prescribed by the President on the advice of the C&AG
- 151 — reports on the Union's accounts to the President, who causes them to be laid before Parliament
- Sections of the DPC Act: 13 audit of expenditure, 14 bodies financed by the Government, 16 receipts, 17 stores and stock, 18 powers, 19 Government companies
Controller General of Accounts (CGA) and railway accounts
- CGA — under the Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure); accounts of civil ministries departmentalised since 1976
- In the Railways, accounts and audit separated from 1 April 1929; the accounts are kept by the Railways' own Accounts Department
- Member (Finance) in the Railway Board; Principal Financial Adviser (PFA) at the zone; Senior Divisional Finance Manager at the division
- Audit of the Railways is done by the C&AG's railway audit wing (Principal Director of Audit)
5Disposal of Audit Objections and Draft Paras
In simple wordsFrom an audit objection to a draft para — and their timely disposal.
- Types of audit: against provision of funds, regularity (according to the rules), sanction (of the competent authority), propriety, and performance (economy, efficiency, effectiveness — the 3Es).
- Sequence: Inspection report (Parts I/II) → special letter → Statement of Facts → draft para → C&AG's report (in Parliament) → examination by the PAC → Action Taken Note (ATN).
- Replies at every stage in time and with facts — what happened, why it happened, what correction was made, whose responsibility was fixed, recovery or regularisation.
- A draft para is normally answered within 6 weeks; the reply is approved at a higher level (a case going up to the Board).
- The ATN on a report laid in Parliament is normally due within 4 months.
- The department concerned and the Accounts Department work together in preparing replies; the facts should be verified with accounts before replying.
- A recurring objection = a weakness in the system — don't just reply, improve the procedure.
ExampleAudit found that a division had bought sleeper fastenings equal to 3 years' consumption without need. The department did not reply to the special letter, so a Statement of Facts was issued, and then a draft para. The reply must explain — how the requirement was assessed, where the surplus will be used, what improvement has been made for the future and what responsibility has been fixed.
RememberQuick revision —
- 265 taxes by law; 266 Consolidated Fund and Public Account; 267 Contingency Fund; 114(3) — no withdrawal without an Appropriation Act.
- 113 — the Lok Sabha can reduce a demand, not increase it; no vote on charged items. Cuts: policy ₹1, economy a specified amount, token ₹100.
- 115 supplementary/additional/excess; 116 vote on account; a single demand for grants for the Railways (from 2017-18).
- Propriety: like one's own money; not for one's own benefit; not for a particular section (insignificant amount, court, recognised policy — exceptions); allowances not a source of profit.
- C&AG: 148–151, 6 years/65 years; DPC Act 1971 (13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19). Accounts and audit separate in the Railways since 1929.
- PAC 22 (15+7), Chairman from the opposition; Estimates Committee 30; objection → special letter → Statement of Facts → draft para (6 weeks) → report → ATN (4 months).
Exam trap
- The Lok Sabha can reduce a demand for grants, not increase it; no vote on charged expenditure.
- Three exceptions to the "not for a particular section" canon — insignificant amount, court order, recognised policy.
- Accounts and audit separate in the Railways since 1929.