In simple wordsThe Accounts Stock Verifier (ASV) of the Accounts Department personally counts, weighs or measures the material kept in stores depots, sheds, workshops and on the line, to see whether what is written in the books is actually on the ground. After coming to this post he has to pass the examination under Appendix-4 of IREM Vol. I — otherwise he is sent back to his parent cadre.
1.1What Appendix-4 Is
At the end of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual Vol. I (revised edition 1989), four appendices relate to examinations of the Accounts Department:
| Appendix | Subject |
|---|---|
| Appendix-1 | IRAS probationary officers |
| Appendix-2 | Qualifying examination for promotion above Accounts Clerk, up to Sr. Accountant (formerly AA) |
| Appendix-3 / 3A | Qualifying examination for SSO (Accounts), SSO (Traffic Inspection), SSO (Stores Inspection) |
| Appendix-4 | Promotion to and confirmation in the rank of Stock Verifiers |
Appendix-4 has 8 paras in all — para 1 (who will become an ASV), para 2 (confirmation and purpose of the examination), para 3 (experience before the examination), para 4 (pattern of the examination), para 5 (who conducts the examination), para 6 (chances and time limit), para 7 (exemption), para 8 (power to change the rules).
1.2Who Comes to the ASV Post — Para 1 (ACS 276)
In simple wordsThe ASV post is a Level-6 post with outdoor work. It is filled first from Accounts Assistants, failing them from Junior Accounts Assistants, then from the Cash & Pay department, then from Accounts Clerks and finally from Junior Shroffs — in this order.
The Railway Board changed para 1 by issuing Advance Correction Slip (ACS) 276 with RBA 08/2022 (dated 31.01.2022). ASV (Level-6) posts are now filled in this order of preference — each next source only when nobody is available/willing from the previous one:
| Order | Source (7th CPC) | Condition | Appendix-2 condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| (i) | Accounts Assistant, Level-6 — PFA's office | Seniority and suitability, including suitability for outdoor work | Not mentioned (they are already in a qualified cadre) |
| (ii) | Junior Accounts Assistant (JAA), Level-5 | Holding the post substantively, at least 2 years in that grade | Must have passed Appendix-2; the GM may relax it in special cases |
| (iii) | Staff of the Cash & Pay department, Level-4 to Level-6 | At least 5 years of service | Passed Appendix-2; GM may relax |
| (iv) | Accounts Clerk, Level-2 | 5 years of regular service in the Accounts Department | Passed Appendix-2; GM may relax |
| (v) | Junior Shroff, Level-2 | 5 years of service in Level-2 | Passed Appendix-2; GM may relax |
ExampleA division has 2 ASV vacancies. No Accounts Assistant is willing; one JAA (3 years' service, Appendix-2 passed) is willing. The first post will be filled by that JAA. For the second post, Cash & Pay staff of Level-4 to 6 with 5 years' service who have passed Appendix-2 will now be considered; if none is found, then Accounts Clerks (5 years, Appendix-2 passed), then Junior Shroffs.
1.3Confirmation and Purpose of the Examination — Para 2
A selected person becomes eligible for confirmation as a stock verifier after at least one year of satisfactory officiating service and on passing the departmental examination. This examination tests:
- general acquaintance with the various classes of stores;
- the procedure followed in stores depots and the accounts office;
- practical knowledge of the procedure for verification of stock and stores;
- the adjustments arising out of verification;
- preparation and disposal of stock verification reports.
In simple wordsThe examination is less "bookish" and more "practical" — types of stores, the work of a depot, the rules for counting-weighing-measuring, the stock sheet and its disposal.
1.4Experience Before the Examination — Para 3 (15 Branches)
Before appearing in the examination, an officiating stock verifier should gain experience of the work of these 15 branches:
| No. | Branch | No. | Branch |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Loco depot | 9 | Engine shed stores |
| 2 | Carriage & Wagon (C&W) depot | 10 | Train Examiner (TXR) stores |
| 3 | Signal shop | 11 | Medical equipment |
| 4 | Power house electrical stores | 12 | Office tools and plant (T&P) |
| 5 | General stores | 13 | Stationery stores |
| 6 | Permanent Way (P.Way) materials | 14 | Stores accounts office — methods of and reasons for stores adjustments |
| 7 | Engineering stores | 15 | Disposal of stock verifiers' reports |
| 8 | Traffic stores |
RememberThe last two of the 15 branches (Nos. 14 and 15) are not depots but the work of the accounts office — methods/reasons of adjustments and disposal of reports. Detailed practical guidance for each branch is in Chapter 9.
1.5Pattern of the Examination — Old and New (Paras 4, 5)
- Old rule: The examination consisted of a written paper and a viva voce; to pass, 50% of the maximum marks was required in each separately. The examination was conducted by the head of each office, with the assistance of an officer of the Stores Department, who also fixed the intervals.
- New rule — RBA 22/2025, ACS 293 (dated 02.07.2025): paras 4 and 5 were changed —
- a single paper, MCQ-based, of 100 marks;
- minimum 40% to pass;
- viva voce abolished;
- examination in CBT (computer-based) mode, by the zonal railway in coordination with the RRB.
Nodal railway — RBA 28/2025 (dated 29.09.2025): following the instructions to hold the Accounts Department's departmental examinations in CBT (RBA 19/2025, dated 17.06.2025), the Northern Railway (NR) has been nominated nodal railway for Appendix-2 and the North Western Railway (NWR) for Appendix-4. The nodal railway conducts the examination together with the nominated RRB; correspondence relating to Appendix-4 is to be made directly with the nodal railway. For other selections/examinations, each railway conducts the CBT itself as per the RRB's detailed SOP of 21.08.2025.
LatestThe new form of paras 4–5 (100 marks, 40%, no viva, CBT) is in force from 02.07.2025; the nodal railway for Appendix-4 is NWR (RBA 28/2025). The number of questions, duration and negative marking are not stated in the notified rule — for practice, this app's mock tests assume 100 questions, 2 hours, no negative marking (as in Appendix-2).
1.6Chances, Time Limit and Result — Para 6
| Period | Rule |
|---|---|
| Board's letter 14.05.2001 | 2 attempts, within 4 years of becoming an ASV; no increment until passed; failing both → reversion to the substantive post; examination at least once a year |
| Later amendment | 3 chances, within 4 years; failure → return to the parent cadre |
| ACS 278 (RBE 113/2022, dated 12.09.2022) | 4 chances, within 5 years of coming to the ASV post; failure → return to the parent cadre |
In simple wordsToday's rule — "four chances, five years". If you don't pass even in four attempts within five years, you go back to the cadre you came from.
ExampleShri K became an ASV on 15.03.2023. He has a maximum of 4 chances up to 14.03.2028. If he fails in the 2024, 2025 and 2026 examinations, he must take the fourth chance in an examination held before 14.03.2028; if he fails that too, or time runs out, he returns to the parent cadre.
The Board gave this relaxation because a zonal railway reported that few willing candidates come from the feeder cadres and many employees could not pass the examination in 3 chances/4 years.
1.7Exemption and Amendment — Paras 7, 8
- Para 7: Stock verifiers who have passed the Appendix-3 examination in the Inspector of Stores Accounts (ISA) group need not pass Appendix-4 for confirmation and increments.
- Para 8: No change can be made in these rules without the prior approval of the Railway Board.
1.8History of Incentives (in brief)
| Order | Provision |
|---|---|
| 03.03.1989 | 3 advance increments to an ASV (then grade ₹1400-2600) on passing Appendix-4 (from 01.01.1986) |
| 31.05.2001 | In the 5th CPC (₹5000-8000), a special allowance of ₹240 per month in place of 3 increments (from 01.01.1996; a later letter clarified the effective date as 01.06.1996) |
| 2014 | Special allowance of ₹1000 per month on passing Appendix-4 for ASVs who came from the Cash & Pay department (GP ₹4200) |
NoteThis table is only to explain the history; which allowance currently applies to an employee should be checked from the latest order of his railway.
Summary table
| Point | Rule |
|---|---|
| Location of the rule | IREM Vol. I, Appendix-4 (8 paras) |
| Post | Accounts Stock Verifier (ASV), Level-6, outdoor work |
| Order of filling (ACS 276, RBA 08/2022) | AA → JAA (2 years) → Cash & Pay L-4 to 6 (5 years) → Accounts Clerk (5 years) → Junior Shroff (5 years) |
| Appendix-2 condition | Required for (ii) to (v); GM may relax in special cases |
| Confirmation | At least 1 year of officiating service + passing the examination |
| Experience before the examination | 15 branches (para 3) |
| Examination (ACS 293, 02.07.2025) | 1 MCQ paper, 100 marks, 40% to pass, no viva, CBT (in coordination with the RRB) |
| Nodal railway (RBA 28/2025) | Appendix-4 — NWR; Appendix-2 — NR |
| Chances (ACS 278, RBE 113/2022) | 4 chances, within 5 years; failure → parent cadre |
| Exemption (para 7) | Passed Appendix-3 (ISA group) |
| Amendment (para 8) | Only with the prior approval of the Railway Board |
Remember100 marks — 40% — no viva — CBT — NWR nodal; "four chances, five years"; 2 years for a JAA, 5 years for all the others.
Exam trapThe old "written + viva, 50% in each" no longer applies. "3 chances / 4 years" is also old — from 12.09.2022 it is 4 chances / 5 years. No separate Appendix-2 condition is written for the Accounts Assistant (order i); it applies to the other four.