7.1Finance Member in Tender Committee (Accounts Code 1510)
In simple wordsEvery Tender Committee (TC) must have a Member (Finance).
Example (Finance Member in TC)In a work with an estimated value of ₹6 crore, the rate of L1 is 22% above the estimate.
- The Finance Member checks — was the estimate old (rates based on 2-year-old SOR)? Comparison with the Last Accepted Rate (LAR)? Where is the hike item-wise — are any one or two items abnormally high (unbalanced rates)?
- Analysis revealed that bringing the estimate to today's market price makes L1 only 7% above → TC recommended negotiation only with L1 (CVC instructions), the rate was fixed at 4% above and accepted.
- This entire analysis remains recorded in the Finance Member's briefing note so that the reasoning is clear before the Accepting Authority.
- Finance Officers are members of Tender Committees at both levels — Headquarters and Division.
- Finance Member — Checking of tender tabulation and briefing note, advising the committee, and suggesting the most advantageous tender.
- Rules — Finance Code Chapter VI (Contracts — General Principles) and Engineering Code (Tender-Contract Chapter).
- Extension of Works TC (2/3 members, direct acceptance ₹50 lakh, acceptance powers 13.09.2024) — in Contracts and Tenders chapter.
Checks by Finance Member — Main Points
- Tender system (Open/Limited/SLT/Single) with competent sanction and Finance Concurrence.
- Notice period, publication.
- Bid Security — amount/exemption.
- Eligibility — Technical, Financial (V/N), Bidding Capacity.
- Reasonableness of Rates — Estimate, LAR, Market, Rate Analysis; unbalanced rates.
- Negotiation/Counter-offer — CVC (Central Vigilance Commission) instructions, L1 only.
- Funds and sanctioned estimate.
- Correct Sanctioning Authority.