21.1Numbers and Paras
In simple wordsEvaluation questions mostly focus on Para numbers, rates, and formulas — all in one place here.
Summary Table
| Subject | Correct | Common Mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Financial Appraisal — Code | Finance Code Volume I Chapter II | Chapter VI (That is Contracts) |
| Minimum DCF (Discounted Cash Flow) Return (Current) | 10% — Board Letter 05.10.2017; Para 204 | 14% (This is the old benchmark) |
| Old Benchmark (2006–2014 Parliamentary reply, CAG) | 14% | 12% |
| PIB's Traditional Criteria | 12% (FIRR/EIRR) | 14% |
| Exemption from Justification | Para 202 — Statutory, Safety (unavoidable), Passenger Amenities, Labour Welfare (excluding residential buildings) | "Customer Amenities" (Before ACS-01) |
| ACS-01, Finance Code Vol I (2022 Edition) | 01.02.2023 — 202(c) | — |
| Finance Advice — "Prudent Person" | Para 203 / 116 | — |
| Standards of Financial Propriety | Para 116 — Four | Five |
| Rolling Stock Cost Included | Para 208 (New Line/Capacity Works) | — |
| Sinking Fund Table | Annexure B — 2–8%, up to 100 years | — |
| Codal Life | Para 219; ACS-62 (24.05.2006) | — |
| Three Methods | Para 220 — ARR (Accounting Rate of Return), Payback, DCF | — |
| Code ARR Example | 9.2% (Initial), 18.4% (Average Investment) | — |
| Payback | Not in vogue; Consult with FA&CAO (Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer) | Prescribed method |
| Code DCF — ₹18,000/₹4,000×10 | 18% | 22% |
| Code DCF — ₹4 lakh/₹1 lakh×10 | 21.41%; spread over 3 years ≈18% | — |
| Evaluation Period (Prevalent) | Construction + 30 years | 50 years |
| Economic Appraisal | Economic Adviser — Para 235, Annexure F; 235A — I | — |
| DPR (Detailed Project Report) Guidelines | Annexure J | — |
| Productivity Test | Above ₹1 crore, 5–7 years (248); Low-return above ₹50 lakh (249) | ₹10 crore, 10 years |
| New Line — Form 244 | 31 December; 11 years; 6th & 11th year | 30 June |
| Traffic Statistics | 1 August | — |
| Register of Selected Works | Half-yearly review | Monthly |
| Purchase Order Vetting | Above ₹10,000; 10% Test Check on lower | ₹1 lakh |
| FA&CAO Designation | Wedgwood Committee 1937; 1938 experiment, 1941 permanent | 1924 |
| Separate Finance Branch | 1947 | 1929 |
| Accounts–Audit Separation | 1929 | 1950 |
| DoE (Department of Expenditure) OM (Office Memorandum) | 05.08.2016 | — |