18.1Objective
In simple wordsChecking after a project has been operational whether the benefits envisioned were actually received or not.
Why is this necessary — At the time of sanction, all figures are estimates — how much traffic will be received, what will be the cost, when will the project be completed. Real figures emerge after the project is operational. If it is repeatedly found that traffic is only half of the estimate, the survey of future projects is improved; if costs increase by 40% every time, the method of preparing estimates is rectified. Therefore, it is called "Productivity Test" or "Post-Project Evaluation".
ExampleA chord-line was sanctioned at ₹600 crore on the estimate that 8 MT of goods and a 12% return would be achieved. Upon completion, the cost came to ₹780 crore and an average of 5 MT of goods was received in the first 5 years.
- In Form 244 (New Line) / Productivity Test (Open-line works), the actual return was calculated using the same methodology — approximately 6%.
- The GM (General Manager) explained the reasons for the variance — 3-year delay in construction (cost escalation), non-commencement of production by a major industry (traffic shortfall).
- The Board uses these lessons in the examination of future DPRs (Detailed Project Reports).
- Financial Appraisal of an investment proposal is done not only before sanction, but also some time after the start of operations — to see whether the return expected at the Estimate-level was actually achieved.
- Results improve future decisions (accuracy of traffic estimation, cost estimation).
- Accounts Code 1519 — The Finance Branch compares actual versus estimated earnings/savings (बचत) of works sanctioned on the basis of financial return; separate records for selected works.