10.1Provision vs Reserve
In simple wordsProvision = money kept aside before profit for a known liability/loss (a charge on profit); reserve = money saved out of profit (an appropriation of profit).
Summary table
| Basis | Provision | Reserve |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Amount set aside for a known liability or fall in the value of an asset, whose amount is uncertain | Amount set aside out of profit for future contingencies or strengthening |
| Nature | Charge against profit | Appropriation of profit |
| If there is no profit | Must still be made | Cannot be made |
| In the profit and loss account | Debit (before working out profit) | In the profit and loss appropriation account |
| In the Balance Sheet | Deducted from the asset concerned or on the liabilities side | Under Reserves & Surplus |
| For Dividend | Not available | Usually available (revenue reserve) |
| Examples | Provision for Depreciation, provision for Doubtful Debts, provision for tax | General reserve, dividend equalisation reserve, debenture redemption reserve |
A provision and a reserve both set money aside, but for different reasons. A provision is made for a known liability or a fall in the value of an asset whose exact amount is uncertain — for example, provision for depreciation, doubtful debts or tax. It is a charge against profit, debited in the profit and loss account before profit is worked out, and it must be made even if there is no profit.
A reserve is set aside out of profit for future contingencies or to strengthen the business — for example, a general reserve or debenture redemption reserve. It is an appropriation of profit, shown in the appropriation account, and cannot be made if there is no profit. In the balance sheet, a provision is deducted from the asset or shown as a liability, while a reserve appears under reserves and surplus and, if a revenue reserve, can usually be used for dividend. For example, setting aside 5% (₹2,500) of debtors of ₹50,000 because some may go bad is a provision, whereas putting ₹1 lakh out of profit into a "general reserve" is a reserve.
As per AS-29 a provision is made only when — (1) there is a present obligation from a past event, (2) an outflow of resources is probable, (3) a reliable estimate of the amount can be made.
Types of reserves
| Type | Details |
|---|---|
| Revenue Reserve | From normal operating profits — general reserve (without a specific purpose) and specific reserves (dividend equalisation, debenture redemption, workmen's compensation) |
| Capital Reserve | From capital profits — profit on sale of fixed assets, profit on reissue of forfeited shares, profit on amalgamation, pre-incorporation profit; normally not for dividend |
| Secret Reserve | Not visible in the balance sheet — by showing assets at lower value/liabilities higher (excessive depreciation); banks, insurance companies (earlier) |
| Reserve Fund | When the amount of the reserve is invested in outside securities |
Reserves are classified by where the profit came from and how they are shown. A revenue reserve comes from normal operating profit; it may be a general reserve without a specific purpose or a specific reserve such as dividend equalisation or debenture redemption. A capital reserve comes from capital profits — profit on sale of fixed assets, reissue of forfeited shares, amalgamation, or pre-incorporation profit — and is normally not used for dividend.
A secret reserve does not appear in the balance sheet; it is created by showing assets at less than their value or liabilities at more, for instance by excessive depreciation. A reserve fund is a reserve whose amount has been invested in outside securities, so the money is available when needed.
Securities Premium — capital in nature; its use is limited to the purposes stated in Companies Act 2013 Section 52 (topic 18).